| Berkeley Parents Network |
| Home | Members | Post a Msg | Reviews | Advice | Subscribe | Help/FAQ | What's New |
I am moving to the East Bay and am thinking about sending my son to Grand Lake Montessori. Any recent opinions/experiences from parents that have a preschooler there would be appreciated.
Re: Thinking of switching our 7-year-old to a Montessori school
My son is now in preschool at Grand Lake Montessori, and we are
extremely happy
there. I know that the school intends to expand its elementary program
over the
next several years, so you may have some flexibility with application
dates and
deadlines. We are now considering the many possibilities for him,
whether to keep
him at GLM, transfer to another private school after the kindergarten
year, or move
to an area with good public schools. I would feel quite confident about
keeping him
at GLM for elementary, even though I had not seriously considered
Montessori
schools for elementary when he started.
Happy GLM parent
My daughter is starting at Grand Lake Montessori in the fall. She'll be on the very young side of the pre-schoolers in Ms. Leck's class. I'm wondering if parents of other children who are either in that class now or will be in it in the fall would be interested in meeting so our children can get to know each other before school starts and feel more comfortable already knowing a few other kids in the class. rachel
Would like to get any feedback/firsthand experiences about Grand Lake Montessori (aka Casa dei Bambini). Most of the reviews are a couple of years old. We have only started looking at preschools and realize there is a range of styles with regard to the Montessori approach -- so we will definitely visit more. How would you describe GLM's approach and culture? Any issues with staff turnover? If you were interested in a specific teacher/classroom, did the school take your preferences into consideration?
As far as the school environment, I think they take the best of Montessori, without overdoing it. They don't freak out if you let your kid watch Blue's Clues at home, for example. Also, they really do let kids work at their own pace, gently encouraging them to take on new ''work''. I know that's the whole idea behind Montessori, but it is nice to see it in action.
Okay. I swear I don't work for them. But I also have to say that they are very diverse, both in the staff and the student body.
To me, the downside is their aftercare. I have found it to be mostly custodial. Much less nurturing and organized than the rest of the day. (School day ends at 2:45.) As a result, I have tried to get my kids at 2:45 or have a babysitter get them at that time.
One more nice thing if you live in Oakland is that you can stay for Kindergarten if you haven't negotiated a good setup for elementary yet. For that matter, you can stay for elementary, though the program seemed somewhat small and limited to me. Feel free to e-mail me with any more questions.
k_a
In primary, you would be amazed to see a room full of 3 to 5 year olds quietly doing ''work'' which they select themselves from materials accessible throughout the classroom, and respecting each other's space. The teachers somehow create this scene with quiet prompting and gentle re-direction as needed. They are very skillful with the kids. Although there is, of course, some turn-over in the staff, the school is very careful to explain when a change (of any kind) to the kids' routine is coming so that they are not surprised/upset.
Susanna
The teachers are nuturing and really get to know the kids well. There is great tenure there amongst them - they come to the school and they stay. They invest a lot of their time to make the school a fun place for the kids to be.
As for the classrooms, I know kids in all of them and can't say that one is better than others. I am impressed by the scope of activities available to the kids - and the level of schoolwork that is presented, in addition to more fun, free time (art, music, etc.)
We've been thrilled with our son's development at Casa - he started out going 3 mornings til noon and now goes five days until 3pm, because he loves it there. The attention he receives is truly individual and yet, he has made lots of friends within this warm environment.
Hope this is helpful! Jill
I am looking for any recent advice or reviews from parents with children who are currently in the program or who have recently started. How old was your child when they started? What was there child care situation prior to entering pre-school? Thanks! Stephanie
They do have before and after care. I'm a working parent so I drop my daughter off as early as 7am and pick her up around 6pm. From what I've noticed about my daughter, she is very happy and the teachers are very committed to the children. My daughter looks forward to going to school every day; she's made lots of new friends and is learning something new everyday. I looked at a lot of schools and was very impressed with this school and I visited the school twice. Sometimes other opinions help, but the bottom line is you should visit the school yourself to decide if this is the type of program you want for your child. Good Luck. Cheryl
I have seen the previous comments on the school Grand Lake Montessori aka Casa Dei Bambini. Does anyone have any current opinions of the school, staff, parent participation etc.? I have a two year old son and am considering enrolling him.
Our ambivalence stems from several factors. The school could do better at communicating basic information to parents. Stuff like telling you that if your child wants to have a drink at lunch, you need to provide a cup. Or that our child's spare set of clothes is ''missing.''
However, parents get constant reminders about fundraising and parent participation ''opportunities.'' Sometimes the focus of the school seems to be more about fundraising than the children.
On balance, we are satisfied and our child loves GLM.
We are thinking of sending our 2-year-old daughter to Casa Dei Bambini/Grand Lake Montessori in the fall and have seen both highly enthusiastic and critical reviews on the website. Any recent experiences that folks would like to share? Thanks in advance for your insights.
My son has been attending Casa dei Bambini this past year, and we love it! My three-year old has Miss Leck, Miss Owens and Mr. Tien, all of whom are very talented, patient, loving and encouraging teachers and very special people. In particular, Miss Leck (the lead teacher in that class) provides a rich learning environment, while addressing the emotional needs of the kids and being very open to discuss issues with their parents. She teaches the kids to do things for themselves, which encourages self-esteem and exploration. She encourages parents to participate in the classroom, which occurs often (I have done cooking and art projects, and will read the story of Purim in a few days). I chose her specifically, after sitting in each classroom and watching the teachers. Now that I have been there for a while, I have also become very impressed with the other teachers, although it would be better to hear from someone whose kid is in their classes to know details. Suzanne
We have enjoyed our experience with Casa (also called Grand Lake Montessori now) -- our son has attended since 4/98, starting in the Toddler program at 2 yrs 4 mo. He transitioned to the 3-5 yr old Primary class that Summer. We have seen tremendous growth in him -- verbally, socially, and intellectually. While our nanny of 3.5 yrs speaks English acceptably as a second language, our son's language / reasoning / questioning / logic, we've been told, are quite developed -- attributable in large part to Casa and the joy of learning & investigation they encourage. Starting him at Casa was a hard transition from 2 days a week in a co-op, (probably harder for me than him), but after a few weeks he was very comfortable with his 5 day 8:30 - 12:30 schedule there. Our daughter jumped right in this May 2000 in the Toddler class and we have experienced considerable growth in language and sharing even since then. We love the classrooms, the teachers (especially Miss Allen, Miss Church, & Miss Leck), and organization & apparent simplicity of the materials -- now understanding further how the learning grows with more advanced use of the same materials -- we find it a great complement to our less organized, less simple, less structured home environment. The diversity of staff & students is the best I've come across in the more than dozen pre-schools we looked at, and while not inexpensive, appears to be somewhat in line with many other schools. We've especially enjoyed the flexibility of schedule (childcare avail 7am - 6pm if needed), on the rare occasions needed, and have really appreciated meeting & getting to know the parents -- many of whom are good friends now. Good luck. Happy to chat off-line.
Starc
Probably the biggest challenge for us was the responsibility of understanding the Montessori approach to a child's learning. We had only a passing understanding of Montessori and chose the school because we were impressed by a number of impressions: observing the children in the classroom - totally engaged in their activities; the teachers moving around the classroom from child to child answering questions and giving direction; the responsiveness of the school administrators to questions and concerns; and the seemingly welcome involvement of parents. All the interactions we observed or participated in were carried out with respect for the other and open interest and involvement.
The school supplied us with good reading material and recommended
literature
on Montessori as well. We are invited regularly to participate in school
activities, including educational, social and fundraising events.
Hope this helps.
Mary
We like the Montessori focus on learning to do things on one's own (get dressed, wash your dish, wipe the table..) Also, the multi-age groupings and the great learning materials. I also REALLY appreciate the school's ethnic diversity (among kids AND teachers). The grounds of the school are pretty, with separate playground for the toddler class (which I wanted).
On the downside, it is not cheap (667/month for fulltime toddler), there is
no 4 day option (either 3 or 5). I also wished for more clear
communication
from the school to parents about certain things. There is not a cozy and
cohesive community of parents at the school, though I have found parents
very
accessible if I called or approached
them with questions. We now exchange childcare and play dates with
other
families. I would not recommend the school to parents who are
uncomfortable
with Montessori philosophy ('cause it's definitely Montessori, which we
love,
but it's not for everybody)
Peggy
Aaron actually did quite well there. It worked for us as in interim solution. But he is an extremely easy and adaptable child. But I never sensed the emergence of the absolute passion he has for his current center (Lakeshore Children's Center). The teachers and the program at Casa made it very clear that they liked Aaron and they thought he made a positive contribution. They wanted us to continue (I suspected that if they did not think Aaron was the "right" kind of kid, they would not have made a point of "inviting" us to continue. I felt like they were offering him admission to Harvard or something. Their attitude about it turned me off.)
But the center didn't do anything for me. I just had uncomfortable vibes about it the whole time. I didn't like that the kids addressed the teachers formally (Ms. X). While I found some parents I really enjoyed talking to, there did not seem to be much of a community around the center. They kept having to cancel field trips because they could not find parents to drive. The time I offered to drive I showed up on a day that I had not been planning to bring Aaron and found out the field trip was cancelled. No one had bothered to call and tell me this. It is VERY expensive and has very long before and aftercare hours. I got the feeling that the long hours were a plus for some parents (understandable, they were for me), but it may have translated into just not having a critical mass of parents able to take time off work to be involved. Also, I suspect the price dampened community spirit too - that people felt "I pay all this money, and then they want MORE time/money/energy..." And there was definitely not the feeling that it would be OK just to hang out there. It is also administered extremely bureaucratically. They seem to take what they are doing VERY seriously. Too seriously for my taste.
And some things I just found odd. For example, they do a dance class for the 3-6 set. But when I was there once and had the opportunity to observe, only about half the class was participating, mostly the girls. I just couldn't figure out why. Aaron wasn't participating. But he participates in his dance class at his new preschool.... Another thing that I now recognize is they didn't do a fraction of the amount of art projects Aaron does now.
But, they do have absolutely AWESOME materials. The stuff they have for the kids to mess with is just incredible. The facilities are very nice. And the environment is way more calm and orderly than where Aaron is now. I could see how it could be exactly the right place for a child who likes beauty and serenity, who is oriented to cognitive development, but not quite ready to get thoroughly in the mix in a situation with larger group size, high focus on getting in the mix socially of a more typical social/developmental preschool.
But, then, I remember observing an amazingly cruel thing on the playground
there... So
I take it back, I'm not sure it would be more socially safe for a more
reserved,
introverted child. Sometimes they have several classrooms of the 3-6 all
out on
the playground at once. I saw this boy grab the hat of this smaller boy,
tease him
about it, and pass it off to a friend. A very clear assertion of dominance.
One
always sees kids get into fights over toys, but this situation shocked me
in that
the boy was deliberately trying to make the other child feel bad. The
teachers did
not see it. But when the boy without his hat began to cry, the teacher did
step in
to help resolve the situation.
Elizabeth
Last updated: Oct 10, 2007
Copyright © 1996-2008 Berkeley Parents Network