Disciplining Other People's Kids
Berkeley Parents Network >
Parenting, Families, & the Community >
Disciplining Other People's Kids
My toddler son is very active and curious. From an early age, I
could see that he would react negatively if he had too many
restrictions, heard too many Nos, and he would do better if I
allowed him to explore relatively freely and to teach him about
dangers. I am proud to say that he is very good about streets,
gentle with animals and children, and very good at managing
himself physically...knowing what is too much for him to handle.
I have a playdate friend whom I see about 1x a week and
frequently she will yell at him ''Come back'' ''get down'' etc...She
is more of a yeller than I am number one, and two, I am more
likely to give him a chance to come back first before yelling.
My question is: Shall I say nothing and let her express her
parenting style (which is what I have been doing) or shall I try
to explain to her what I am trying to do with my son and ask her
not to interfere. Part of me thinks it's fine for her to say what
she wants as he will experience that other people have different
limits. The other part of me wonders if he is confused by this,
wondering, ''why is my mom not saying anything while she yells at me''.
Your advice apreciated
Your friend's interfering (which is what I evaluate it to be)
sounds very difficult and stressful. Your child can learn about
differences in many ways, including by watching that person
parent her own child. How about saying, ''MYOB!'' Just kidding.
I'm sure you can find a respectful and truthful way to tell your
friend that you are upset by her actions, and that in doing so,
you are actually valuing her and your friendship. My experience
is that when I am honest and compassionate about difficult
issues with a friend, our relationship deepens. (Nonviolent
Communication can be helpful. You might check out the BayNVC
website or Marshall Rosenberg's book, Nonviolent Communication:
A Language of Life.)
I've been in your situation, as I had a similar approach to
parenting as you do. In the moment a friend voices the limit I
restate in a kind voice what a parent has said in terms of limit
setting. For instance, 'Mary said 'fill in the blank' because
Mary cares about you and wants to make sure you don't
accidently 'fill in the blank'. Later on I'll tell my child
that life is like this, some people have different limits than
others. And ask if it bothers him or not. Often they figure out
Mary is just being Mary on their own and aren't as sensitive to
the behavior as we fear they might be.
I just want to say, off the subject a bit, that you sound like
such a tolerant and kind person. That just really stood out!
Stand up for your kid! If it's working for both of you, tell her
to back off! If she's your friend, she'll understand; if she
gets upset, drop her like she's hot. To put it another way,
albeit an extreme way, if you are I were hanging out at the park
with our kids, and I said, ''Uh-oh -- did you see what little
Johnny just did? Don't worry, I'll go spank him a few times for
you,'' would you stop me? Or just let me express my parenting style?
(I don't spank, btw...)
My husband and I are close friends with another couple who have
small children, as do we. We spend a lot of time with this
other couple and enjoy their company. What we struggle with,
however, is the wife of the couple who is constantly
disciplining our child, even if they are not doing anything
that seems like disciplining is needed. For example, if our
child is jumping on OUR couch, she will say ''stop that'' to
kid, when it is our couch and we are fine about letting our kid
jump on it. There are many other examples, and again, it isn't
like our kid is hitting her kids or anything like that. It is
really frustrating and makes us uncomfortable as well as our
child, who always looks crestfallen when she says something. My
husband is closer to the husband of this couple than I am to
the wife-should he say something? How do we deal with this? I
don't want to cut off our friendship or anything, but
disciplining other people's kids, unless they are in danger to
themselves or others or ruining something, does not seem
What to do?
I think it's perfectly reasonable to counter their discipline. For
instance, with the couch
incident(s), after your friend has told your child to stop jumping on
the couch just step
in with something like ''she's ok, we let her know that jumping on our
own couch is
fine, but that it's only a special privilege for home!'' Really,
though, just counter every
disciplinary ''attack,'' hopefully they'll get the hint. If that
doesn't work then just be
upfront. If someone thought I was being too invasive I'd want them to
to me so I could correct my behavior.
Everyone has different house rules. Where it might be OK to jump on the
friend ''A.'' It might be tolerated on a couch in the rec room and not
the new couch
for friend ''B.'' Jumping on a couch might be just fine at your house.
Here is the
difficulty- the rules are not posted in clear view.
You have to say it out loud. Tell your friend that you are OK with the
the couch at your house. No one can read your mind.
In addition, keep in mind that some rules for some people don't always
foresight to see that a child can get hurt if too many people are
jumping or if
someone falls down and hits their head. There are reports of children
and sometimes parents don't always have the foresight to have prevented
If the concern is about safety then I think that has to be considered.
As far as your kids go, remind them of the different rules at other
as you learn those rules. The kids may ask why but will deal.
Nanny in the know
It may simply make your friend uncomfortable to be around children
who are jumping on the couch or otherwise being wild. If I was
sitting on your couch and your kids were jumping on it, I would
be tense about them either falling into me, or falling off and
hurting themselves and screaming. I'd be cringing just waiting
for the inevitable. Plus, if they are jumping on the couch,
they're probably not doing it silently. I may be a terrible person,
but I would not be able to relax and enjoy socializing with
you if your kids were jumping on the couch in front of me.
To me, it would seem inconsiderate of you to allow this behavior
in front of me, even if you otherwise tolerate it.
Could you tell your kids "No jumping around guests"? I let my
son do all sorts of things when we are home alone that he can't
do in front of me while my friends are over.
The bottom line is that it is really hard to maintain a friendship
with someone whose parenting style is dramatically different from
yours. You may need to find a more relaxed friend (which would not
Why don't you just immediately say, ''Oh, we're OK with that
actually, thanks.'' Then to the child, ''No problem, honey.'' Or
even go a little further to your child, ''Different houses have
different rules, and jumping on the couch is OK here.'' Or
whatever immediately, loudly to everyone in earshot, no anger,
then continue finishing your sentence. Do this every time as
things arise so they don't build up & your friend will get the
That's a challenging situation. You want your children to have
good manners and respect for the environment when they visit
other people's homes, especially because you want them to be
welcome and invited back. As a teacher I know that what
children learn at home, they take out into the world. I
sometimes have to teach them skills they might not be getting
elsewhere, even though I'm not the parent. We want them all to
have good social and communication skills, problem-solving
skills, and a respect for themselves, others, and the
environment at large. When they take that out into the world,
they are appreciated and valued, and people want to be around
them. It's a gift you give them. You could identify that in
your house you allow jumping on furniture, but that it would
not be a good idea to do that in other places or people's
homes, unless it's okay with the parents, and let your friends
know what you've told them.
I would try to respond lightly by saying something like ''oh, it's
fine if she jumps on our couch.''
I have had this happen plenty w/ my 4 kids. Three of my kids are
boys and are pretty wild, so in our house there are very relaxed
rules about certain things. When people like my mom or well
meaning aunts, uncles and friends discipline them I always say in
a sweet sort of innocent voice, ''Oh, it's alright - I let them
jump on the couch - slide down the hill in their wagon, climb the
50 foot tree out back, jump from the roof to the trampoline etc
etc'' I play it off as if I have no idea that what they are doing
is uncouth or I act as though (and this is true sometimes) it
might seem odd that it is ok w/ me to allow their outrageous
behavior and that I totally get why the discipliner is saying
something BUT that I have learned over the years that I must
carefully choose my battles. You could even explain that to your
friend - something like, ''Oh you know, we let johnny jump on the
couch at home but he knows not to do it at other people's houses
- the thing is, I really don't mind, I like jumping on beds and
couches too - we are just silly that way.'' If you just SAY IT in
the moment and make a joke out of it then the onus is on them.
Oh, I have (more of a had at this point) a friend like that...I
found it easier to cool off the friendship than have her verbally
abuse (and that is really what it is...she is always lecturing my
kids when I am sitting there) my children. I found that this
friend of mine would generally cause my children to bring out
their absolute worst behavior because they couldn't communicate
that this woman was just a bugger to them. Of course, I can't
have my kids sticking at their tongues at an adult or telling her
that they don't care what she says. So there are timeouts...but
why? Because the woman is a nutty control freak! So, I dropped
her and try to keep the toxics to the best of my ability out of
So, my advice...limit your contact to adult only...
You gotta put the smack down.
Tell her straight out to lay off, that you're the parent, not
her, and you'll handle the discipline. You appreciate her good
intentions, but that's not how you want to raise your child, and
you're sure that as friends she can understand.
I bet a million women on this board just thought ''Oh my god, is
she talking about ME?!?!''. I have some friends who are so close
that we discipline each others children as if they were our own.
This doesn't sound like a case of that. Maybe say ''Oh, it's OK.
That couch is super old. We don't mind''. Or something to that
effect. Slightly off topic, I don't think your kid should be
jumping on the couch either!! Maybe she thinks she's doing you a
Couches aren't trampolines
Why not just say, ''oh, it's ok. We let her jump on the couch
here, we don't mind.'' I think your friend probably figures that
she's being helpful. And also she wouldn't want that in her
house, I'd guess. I'd also suspect that you may not be such
close friends for so long if you have such different ideas about
what needs correction, as well as different ideas about what's
appropriate. Personally, I appreciate that my friends help to
notice when my kid is out of line (even though, ironically, it of
course stings when somebody else tells my kid to stop!), and I
have no problem whatsoever directing other people's kids to
behave appropriately in my household, or on common ground. I
don't believe it's appropriate w/ small children to let them run
amok ''unless they are in danger or ruining something'' nor to ''let
them work it out'' until they actually have the skills and
insights to know what decisions they are making. And I don't
appreciate people who fail to correct their kids. What often
''works out'' is that the shrinking violets learn to keep quiet,
and the more aggressive types learn to bully. And none of them
learn good behavior or manners that you can bring to other
locations. However, we all have a right and responsibility to
communicate our own preferences with our kids, and we tend to
gravitate toward people with similar ideas. The two-way
disciplining or correcting that occurs with my friends wouldn't
work if we had different notions about it--and for things that
really don't matter, we let the kids do what the parents clearly
prefer: e.g., if the other parent says ''you don't have to finish
your dinner'' I don't tell the kid to finish his dinner, nor do I
tell my kid he doesn't have to. Mine still has to finish his
dinner (in my house-at their house I assume he doens't have to).
I am first wondering what kind of relationship this is. Does
your husband know the guy through work, so are you concerned
about seeming rude for that reason? My advice would depend on
why are you worried about offending them. If it's because you
don't want to embarrass your husband, then you should talk to
him about it asap. In fact, you should talk to him about it
asap anyway, since he should know what's going on in your head.
Maybe he will have some feedback that will be helpful? If you
don't want to react to this woman with anything but deference
because either that's your personality or that's the kind of
behavior you want your child to emulate (since you're her role
model) but this lady continues to annoy you, I would suggest
doing your best to not spend time with this woman, including
letting your husband know and explaining why you don't want to
spend time with them anymore. No need to make a scene with the
lady if you don't want to, just stop returning phone calls and
start declining offers to hang out. She'll take the hint
eventually. Finally, if you're worried about offending her just
because it seems socially inappropriate, then my suggestion is
to stand up for yourself! This woman is being RUDE and
INAPPROPRIATE. She has no right to boss your child around, and
your daughter might benefit from being defended by you as well
as seeing you stand up for yourself. Your child should also
look to you as the end-all of discipline, not this lady. My
only defense of this woman is that I might find it
disconcerting to be spending time with friends and having their
little ones jumping on the furniture while I am trying to carry
on a conversation, and I would discipline MY kids for doing
that, especially if we had people visiting. But I would NEVER
discipline YOUR kids for doing it in YOUR home, though I admit
that I would be silently thinking to myself, ''Why isn't she
stopping them from doing this?'' (Sorry, but that's just how I
personally feel.) But in Your Home -- You are Queen!! If you
are visiting HER home and they are jumping on her furniture
because they've learned that it's okay to do that at home,
well... But again, why bother visiting or hanging out with
someone who doesn't share the same parenting philosophy if it
can be avoided? Life's too short, in my opinion! I'm sure there
are other families who enjoy a good furniture romp who would be
fun to spend time with =)
My advice is to try as best you can to respond directly to her
comments in the moment that they happen. So for example, if your
kid is jumping on your couch and she says 'stop that', you could
just say, 'actually, Sally, it's fine with us if X jumps on the
couch, thanks.' Then turn to your kid and say, 'it's OK, honey'
so that it is clear to everyone that you are overruling her. If
you are able to politely but firmly push back on her a few times,
hopefully she will get the message that her discipline is not
needed nor welcome in these situations.
If she doesn't get it, then you will need to have a conversation.
In that case, I would try to approach it by saying something
like, ''although we obviously want to support each other in
disciplining the kids when they are hitting or doing something
dangerous, we seem to have different opinions about when to
discipline on things like jumping on the couch, etc, and I am
worried about the kids getting mixed messages. I want to make
sure I respect your rules and vice versa, so what should we do?''
You are definitely in a tricky situation, but I think the more
direct and firm - but clear that it's fine if she wants to tell
HER kid to 'stop it' when jumping on the couch - the more
effective and less disruptive it will be to your relationship.
I'd be straight - up, but calm, before you blow (which you will
if you're like most of us Mama Bear's). something like, ''Heh,
(Mary) I was hoping I could bring something up with you...this
is kind of vulnerable and awkward for me but I really value our
freindship....I've noticed sometimes you correct (my daughter)
and I'm finding I'm uncomfortable with it. Here's what would
work for me: if she's doing something that directly involves
you or your property or just bugs you, please bring it up with
me and I'll talk to her about it [pull it away from her]...but
if it's something related to our home, etc., please leave the
disciplining to me''.
My mother in law was confronted by my husband with the same
(I'm lucky here). To her credit, she didn't get defensive -
but she would forget, to which my husband would have to
PROMPTLY say, ''Mom, I'll handle that,I''m the parent''.
Hope this helps.
Bring it up now while you can maturely, if you care about your
- Good luck....sister
I'm late chiming in on this, but I was struck when reading the
first round of responses that maybe the issue is more deeply
about the discipline differences in your parenting. One of my
kids' best friends is a little wild, talks back to his mother,
does things she's just told him not to (without consequence) -
stuff like that. It really irks me, for several reasons - the
strongest (for me) is that I hate to be around kids like this,
and when I see parents behavior (a) leading directly to kids
behavior (b), it drives me crazy. Also importantly, in the
bigger picture, I hate what this is turning the kids into (kids
I - among others, I'm sure - won't take certain fun places
because they can't be trusted to behave). I also don't want MY
kids picking up on this. And, least defensibly, it just bothers
the controlling part of me to see this happening.
As a result, sometimes I overstep and discipline the kid. I
feel it when I do it; know it's not the best thing to do, and
know it's probably highly annoying to the mother, but sometimes
I'm not perfect. There you have that.
At what point, if any, do the other adults in your kids' lives
have rights to a certain atmosphere? Do they have any rights to
assert their own needs? That's a genuine question.
Sometimes a disciplinarian
I saw your question and the responses. I have been in a similar
situation, only in
this case, I was the person who told both my kid and my friends' kid not
to jump on
my friends couch. My friend clarified that it was ok in their house for
their kid to
jump on the couch, and that they understood that that would not be ok in
house. In turn I acknowledged their house rule but did add that since my
tends to need consistent messages about behavior, that I was not going
to let her
jump on their couch, even that they would be ok with it.
Problem settled. No gritting our teeth, no passive aggressive fall-out,
no big tense
confrontation, no loss of friendship. It all worked out. (FWIW, they
their rule and stopped letting their kid jump on their living room
furniture- but that
was after there were a couple of almost big time bad falls).
not passive agressive
Tricky issue. Maybe your friend gets stressed by kids jumping
on the furniture around her, but is less afraid to talk to the
kid than to ask you to not let it happen. She may seem rude in
your mind, but perhaps you could do more to be a polite host;
try to make sure your adult guests' comfort comes before the
comfort of the kids.
I don't think it's always inapproriate for adults to discipline
someone else's kid, but one must be careful. 2 suggestions: 1)
with the other mom and all the kids, have a pre-play meeting
and say, ''OK, kids, you all know that different houses have
different rules and they must be respected.In our house, you
may jump on the sofa, and in their house you may not.In their
house you may play with toy guns, but not in our house, etc. 2)
If you know there are many differences between you and the
other mom, then maybe plan playdates on neutral ground -
playgrounds or parks, where there's a more accepted etiquette.
I've the same deal with some friends,only I'm the ''stricter''
one. I've decided that when we hang with them, my kids can eat
more junk food, play with more tv-show-related toys, watch
Barbie movies, etc.-the stuff I try to keep them away from at
home. I still make them mind their manners tho, including not
jumping on people's furniture, not using bad language, saying
please/thank you, and keeping the rough play/noise as far away
from us grown ups as possible.(If they are jumping on the
furniture out of sight,it's also out of mind.;-)And they know
that at our house we'll serve veggies and send 'em outside.
IMO,our local communities seem rife with a form of ''parenting
imperialism,'' where our perceived ''needs'' of our own children
are placed above almost everything else: other parent's
feelings, the needs of schools, teachers, coaches, etc. I fear that
this culture of ''My Kids, My Parenting, Above All Else,'' is
steeping our kids in a sense of entitlement, and setting them
up for a hard time later on,when they have to get along with
others but have no diplomacy or compromise skills to do so.
I feel compelled to add my 2 cents because I would be very
uncomfortable trying to visit a friend whose child was bouncing
around on the furniture. Whether or not it is ''allowed'' by the
parents, couldn't you be courteous to your guests and disallow
this disruptive behavior while guests are visiting? Maybe I'm
uptight, but I have had friends whose children are allowed to be
disruptive (i.e. jumping on furniture, loudly demanding their
parent's attention), and it frankly forced me to refrain from
visiting them. Permanently. I know, those are your rules, but if
your friend is telling your child to refrain from jumping on the
sofa, it is correct etiquette to tell your child to stop doing
that. Your guest is the one you should be trying making
comfortable in your home, and your child needs to learn that
there are boundaries to behavior. Sometimes it's okay to jump on
the sofa, but at other times (as in when you have guests), it is
not. If you can't do this, don't invite other people to your
home. It's just rude, and you are not being a good hostess. FYI,
I feel that you are giving your child a serious disservice by
vocalizing to your guest that they are out of bounds, while also
telling your child to ignore another adult's edict. However you
may see it, your child will be under the care of other
authoritarians for the rest of their juvenile life, and if you
teach your child that your rules are always right, you will have
a child who has problems with teachers and other adults in
authority. Take it from me, I had a free hand from my parents,
and It cost me. At the very least it cost me a high school
graduation. Yeah, I know that's a long way from where you are
now, but what you teach your children now is what they will use
as they get older. Get wise, teach your children boundaries.
I have 5 nieces and nephews aged between 1 and 9. We often visit
together as a family, and though I love their energy, I am
increasingly upset by the kids' disrespect for their
grandparents' house and for others. I realize that they're bound
to get rowdier than usual when they're away from home, all
together, and when their parents are relaxing (instead of
actively disciplining them.) I have so far limited my reprimands
to dangerous activities (throwing things) and disrespectful or
irresponsible ones (hitting, leaving the house a mess,) but I
find myself choking back life lessons, especially to the older
two who 'know better.'
As an aunt and not a parent, how much am I allowed to say? I am
sensitive of overstepping the bounds by disciplining someone
else's child, of not being the 'mean' aunt, and of avoiding the
implication that my siblings are poor or inattentive parents
I'd appreciate some sound advice.
It really depends on your relationship with your niece's and nephew's
parents. It is interesting that you didn't even mention your sibling at
all in your post. Certainly the default setting for such a situation
should be that aunts and uncles would have a part in the raising. ''It
takes a village'' is a cliche for a reason. The only thing that would
possibly make that uncomfortable is if there was tension between you and
the kids mom or dad (things of the ''my whole life you've been telling
me what to do, and now your bossing my kids around'' or ''you've always
been judgemental'' variety.) And even then it shouldn't really stop you
from helping guide the kids. I grew up with copious aunts and uncles,
all of whom had no shame in breaking it down to us kids about this or
that behavioral lesson. In many ways we took their advice more seriously
than our own parent's simply because they were not our parents. I can
certainly say that I am a better adult for their involvement.
It is important to remember that discipline is not something you choose
based on how the kid will view you. Instead it is an act of love. You go
out of your way to teach children what you know because you want them to
have happy succesful lives and it means enough to you that you risk
being temporarily unpopular. In all but the most extreme examples, your
intervetion will be remembered by your neices and nephews as a sign that
you cared for them and considered them one of your own.
if you're concerned about your relationship with their parents, you
should talk to your brother or sister about it. But know that regardless
of what happens there, those kids are your family and you should treat
them as such.
one more thing: I don't know if you have kids, but I have to say, the
best part about getting together with the family is that for once I get
to take a break while someone else tells my kid to stop being a jerk.
Maybe your niece's and nephew's parents feel the same way.
Hi, auntie! I was an aunt for 11 nieces and nephews before I became a
mom late in life, and have a lot of sympathy for your dilemma. My
siblings are wonderful parents, but they do have different ideas about
what constitutes an enjoyable family time together! Here's what I ended
up doing (and what I use with my own son when others feel the need to
discipline him): I explained to my nieces and nephews that different
people have different rules and that I would appreciate it if they
helped me with my rules so that I could enjoy my time with them. When I
didn't have kids, I would say, ''I don't live with kids all the time and
you can help me have a better time if you take better care of grandma's
stuff. I worry about it and it's not so much fun for me.'' When they
were helping ME worry less by acting calmer or more respectfully, I
always thanked them. One of my sisters was (is) occassionally annoyed
with me, and annoyed me sometimes by being condescending about my
limited capacity to deal with the chaos of kids. But mostly, everyone
was willing to help me out. I remain (I think!) a favorite aunt who
gets visits now from my older nieces and nephews who act with lovely
respect and affection toward me and their grandparents. And privately,
my parents thanked me later.
Another aunt who's been there
I totally sympathize with your perspective. Nowadays, it is very
perilous to correct other people's children. It is generally the
parents who need to be corrected.
The way I would approach this is to let the parents and children know
that they need to adhere to two simple rules whenever in your house or
around you and your parents:
1) Be nice
2) Respect others' property
Then every misbehaviour can be tied back to one of these rules. A child
should always use nice language, not hit or seem threatening, not
exclude other children, etc. An occasional infraction should only
warrant a warning, but regular infractions and the children and parents
should be dismissed from the house and not invited back. End of story.
Good luck & take care,
I think doing as you said you are already doing--intervening only when
something dangerous or very, very disrespectful is going on, and leaving
the rest up to their parents. Remember that this is a holiday for them,
not just you, and that means relaxing what their everyday duties are
that seem natural to you (i.e. not having to keep things perfectly tidy,
being a bit lax on stricter manners, being a bit more rambunctious than
usual, etc.). Especially the older two, but perhaps all of them, can
feel very violated if someone who they know is not their disciplinarian
is punishing or yelling at them. They know that it is not your job, and
they will resent you for it. You only need to do something when the
situation is dangerous, or permnent harm will be done. Otherwise, it is
their parents' decision, not yours!
I think that in America we tend to be overly sensitive about weighing in
when it isn't ''our'' children. My husband is from India and I see the
exceptionally strong extended families there and part of that is taking
responsibility for good and bad behavior in nieces and nephews. Of
course this needs to be done with finesse so that it creates a positive
situation not a negative one. For example not just barking out
corrections and rules, but providing alternatives for that energy (hey
kids lets go outside and play catch), praising positive behavior (that
was so nice they way you helped your cousin draw that picture) and
making expectations clear in advance. Your siblings should also step up
too with their own kids if things are out of hand and help you identify
what and how to address the situation. I think kids in the end know
someone who helps them act appropriately is someone who really loves
them. I say be actively involved!
Auntie and Mom
It sounds like your nieces and nephews' behavior is bothering you more
than it is your parents, whose house is being turned upside-down. Maybe
your parents accept that when all the kids get together it is designated
''crazy time,'' and they are okay with that. Is it possible for you to
cultivate the same attitude, and turn your attention to having fun with
your siblings? Or if the truth is that the racket and rowdiness stresses
you out after a while (I can certainly relate), maybe you could work
with your sibs to organize some ''quiet time'' activities, like art
projects or video-watching, or designate a ''kid zone'' away from the
adult conversational area. Or maybe you could all go to a park, where
the kids could work their ya-yas out...
I freely discipline other children when they are in my home or otherwise
given over to my care. I'm the adult, it's my rules when I'm around.
In another person's home, I try to watch that my own child conforms to
my rules and be respectful of their rules too... in your case, if the
grandparents want to be lenient in their home, let them... My folks let
my child tear up paper into tiny bits in their home and then they
cheerfully clean it up themselves; that's not allowed here. And I
wasn't allowed such as a child, but grandparents rule differently than
auntie and parent
How do we deal with our undisciplined 5-yr old nephew? The bad
behavior is due to several factors including: parents who argue
in front of him; no consistent discipline (if he receives any
at all); a mother who is overworked & permissive, & an absentee
father. Our nephew is extremely bright & does not have A.D.D.
In the past, we have left the discipline up to his mom, but
the boys behavior is getting worse. Only in kindergarten for
2 weeks, a note has been sent home for spitting & his parents
have already been called in for a parent/teacher conference for
behavior problems. His mom doesnt properly use timeouts &
routinely makes threats that are never carried out. Our
nephew's bad behavior has been discussed amongst the family &
close friends for 3 years now. Were very concerned that our
2.5-yr old & 1-yr old kids will pick up his disrespectful
behavior & nasty language. Also, we dread spending time with
him even though we know were his best family influence.
Holidays are not enjoyable & something we actually dread. Wed
like to start disciplining him when hes in OUR home meaning
wed give him up to 3 timeouts before asking his mom to take
him home. Having him leave our home & not play with his
cousins seems to be the only punishment that he might respond
to that WE can impose. What do people think of this idea?
Caring But Desperate Auntie
When he's at your house, it is completely reasonable to tell him
that he needs to follow your rules, and it is completely
reasonable to tell him that if he can't do that, he will have to
leave. It would be a good idea to tell his mother first, maybe
over the phone while arranging the visit, so she also knows what
Believe me, after you do it once, it is unlikely to have to
After reading your message, I felt sad for the mother of this
little boy. You seem to be so sure of your own parenting
techniques (even though your own children are both under three).
You even describe yourselves as this child's ''best'' family
influence, and yet the tone of your message suggests otherwise.
You don't say exactly what this boy is doing, but having
witnessed other intelligent boys (the most difficult to
manipulate with handy techniques) and their reactions to family
stress, especially an absent father, nothing would surprise me.
If this child's behavior is truly outrageous it might be a
mental health issue, which is more likely to be caused by trauma
or some internal factor than his mother's refusal to use ''proper
discipline''. If he really has issues like this, his ''over-
worked'' mother is probably baring the brunt of it, especially if
his dad is not around, and would probably benefit more from
compassionate understanding than the smug tsk-tsking of family
And to the mother in question, if you've been reading all of
this, my heart goes out to you. There are people out there
(therapists, teachers, other experienced parents) who will be
much more understanding than your family has been. I suggest you
seek them out.
We recently had an episode at my parent's house (3 hrs away in
the Sierra foothills) where my father angrily snapped at our 6-
yr old in our presence for climbing on the furniture. My dad,
who has always had a short fuse, had already been arguing with
my mother. My son, who already had been warned about not
climbing on the furniture but ''forgot'', stood up on the living
room chair. I was in the process of dealing with his behavior
by reminding him that climbing on the furniture was unacceptable
when my dad yelled over me at my 6-yr. My wife then asked my
dad to leave disciplining our son to us and my father responded
by implying that we couldn't control our kids and reminding us
that in his house he has the right to ''discipline'' his grandkids
in our presence.
Now, I don't have a problem with his not wanting my kids to
climb on the furniture, but undercutting my authority with my
son was more than I could handle and I layed into him telling
him that we were all aware of his opinion and I wished he could
keep it to himself. He stormed out never to be seen for the
rest of the weekend (this happened on Saturday). The whole
irony is, my son and daughter are the best behaved of all my
parents' grandchildren. I told my mother over the phone that I
will not be driving 3 hrs each way only to subject my kids to
what I had to endure growing up.. that we would not be visiting
until my father can control his temper. It's upsetting to all
of us because my kids adore their grandparents and don't really
understand why my dad disappeared as he did. How should I
approach this going forward? Did I overreact to his
Rob - You need to rememebr, it is your father's home. I think
his being rude to your wife was uncalled for, but as far as
setting and maintaining the rules in the house, he definitley
has the final say. If you are worried about you childrens'
safety, then forego future visits to your folks house or have a
long talk with your dad explaining that although you respect him
as your father, you absolutley will not allow him to strike your
children. But after your son repeatedly broke the rules in his
house and you and your wife failed to address it, I think he was
in his right to tell your son to stop, even if it was louder and
more forcefully than you are your wife were willing to do. Good
luck reconciling with your parents.
Your situation sounds like a difficult one. It sounds to me
like everyone reacted strongly, with nothing really getting
While you may disagree, here is my opinion.
1) I believe that the people whose house children are visiting
have the right and responsibility to set the limits on
children's behavior. It is best, of course, if these limits can
be set firmly and clearly, without emotional outbursts.
2) It sounds to me like there is a *lot* of ''old business'' from
your childhood that is surfacing in your family. It really
needs to be resolved. If you don't think you can (or want to)
work it out with your father, then work it out for yourself.
3) Until these things get worked out, I'd have you and your
children spend time with their grandparents in a neutral
location, with you staying in a nearby hotel and making only
brief forays to their home with the children.
When my son was 6 (20 years ago now), I took him to my parent's
home in Texas as part of the celebration of a younger sister's
wedding. My son behaved in ways I had never, ever seen him
behave before. For example, prior to the outdoor rehearsal
dinner barbecue, he took several cans of pop out of the tin tubs
where they were cooling and threw them against the trees
as ''bombs,'' making a terrible mess. I realized later that my
son was reacting to the negative energy that was in and around
my parents and their home. It was as if the energy that was
there ''exploded'' inside of him and he had to release it in some
way. It helped me to see what I had been up against when I was
growing up. The minute we left, he returned to his well-behaved
self. My parents forever thought I was bringing up a monster!
My best to you in this. I think taking a stand is better than
not taking one, but having the situation where your children are
deprived of grandparents because of the grandfather's immaturity
and the fact that you have not worked out your own feelings
about him, is sad. I hope you can work things out, soon.
I imagine that many of the people on this list had parents who
were ''stricter'' disciplinarians than they are -- I know I did.
When we go home I am always conscious that our way of dealing
with our son's behavior may very well strike my parents as
permissive, and I have to remind myself pretty constantly not to
worry about this. At the same time, I try (as it seems you do)
to respect the rules they have at their house.
Your posting struck a chord with me because my Dad, like yours,
was and is a yeller. I hated being yelled at and to this day
I'll jump a foot if someone in the vicinity yells (I don't like
it when my husband shouts at my child or, of course, at me).
When we go home, I find myself trying to protect my son from my
Dad's anger. It's usually not directed at my son, really, but
just a function of how tired or irritated my father happens to
feel. I have told my son that Grandpa has a bad temper, that he
sometimes shouts, and that it's not a sign that he doesn't care
about him. (I am assuming that there's no real abuse in the form
of cursing or name-calling or denigrating in your father's
words?) So far there has not been any incident that led my son
to pull back from his grandfather. He has however observed my
Dad's anger in action and is rather careful around him. You may
have been overreacting be! cause of your own experience with your
father's anger. Your son will not be seeing his grandfather often
enough for your father's anger to impinge much on his world.
It's not like your experience, where you had to walk on tiptoe
(if you're like me and my siblings) most of the time. Your son,
with your help, should be able to obey his grandfather and shrug
off the difference in style.
While it was not good that your father interrupted you in the
process of disciplining your child and then argued with you and
stormed off, all of these things are further indicators of his
bad temper, of which you are aware. Probably it is true that
your father should be able to discipline your children in his
house (within reasonable limits -- you actually agreed that your
children shouldn't be playing on the furniture), and probably it
is true that he should be able to correct them even in your
presence, as long as you are on the same page (you agree on the
rules and he is not abusive). Probably it is not good that you
suggested that he keep his opinions to himself. He does have a
right to express his opinions in his own home, and in fact you
essentially agreed with him in this case.
It sounds to me as if the real issue is not the specific instance
of having your authority undermined (in your Dad's mind, you
undermined his), but your Dad's bad temper and the possible
impact it will have on your kids (and the continued impact it has
on you). There also may be (as there is in my case) some
residual anger at your mother for not standing up for you when
you were young. Thus your conversation with her (not your Dad)
about how you will be withdrawing from the family until/unless
things improve. Is that what you really want? It seems you will
have to weigh whether a flawed relationship with grandparents
will be better for your kids than no relationship at all. I
think that as long as the grandparent is not abusive, a
controlled kind of contact (short visits, with patience
exercised) might be fine. For your kids. You may be the one who
wants to stay out of the mix...
another ch! ild of Old Yeller
Sounds like everyone was having a bad day. Your father
shouldn't have yelled at the 6 yr old -- your wife shouldn't
have criticized him in front of anyone else. He certainly
shouldn't have said what he did in response.
For you to then yell at him for ''undercutting your authority''
and being rude to your wife, while you were a guest in his
house... yes, that was out of line. In some sense, his leaving
for the duration of the weekend was the most sensible thing
anyone did that day.
The appropriate response would actually have been for you
and your family to pack up and go after his outburst -- not for
YOU to yell and HIM to go. Its his house. If you don't like it,
get out. If you're lucky, voting with your feet will encourage
him to control himself and maybe get some help with his
That said, in your position I'm pretty sure I would have said
nothing, stayed, and defiinitely kept the 6 year-old in another
room for the rest of the wkd, so it didn't happen again -- but
that's cuz I'm a chicken.... not because its the right thing to
Well, my personal opinion is that your father has a problem
handling anger and frustration appropriately, and is humiliated
and offended when he is told by others that they'd appreciate
him exercising better control. That said, you certainly have
the right to refuse to expose your child to this. It's true,
you will not be able to see the grandparents as often under
these circumstances, but that's the choice you face. I don't
think you overreacted, it's simply a choice you've made based
upon how much this behavior has historically bothered you and
how harmful it's been to you and, ! by extension, how harmful you
think it will be for your son.
Since your father would only have ''the right'' to behave poorly
in his own house, perhaps you could suggest outings on more
neutral ground? Suggest taking your son on a fun outing
somewhere else -- fruit picking, a train ride, a park, etc. --
somewhere in the middle. Or invite them to your house. You
don't need to highlight why -- you can address it if another
situation arises or if they ask. There's the possibility that
one or both of them won't want to do this, but then they are
making the choice not to see their grandchildren.
The way I see it, everyone involved just needs to closely
examine their priorities here -- does your father's behavior
bother you enough to avoid visiting him in his home, even if it
means less contact with your parents? Are your parents willing
to sacrifice time with their family for the sake of pride or
shame? You need to do what's best for your children and for
you, whether that means visiting the grandparents or not. In
the end, you can't control what your parents do, but you can
control your own choices. I suspect that simply continuing to
visit your parents without anything changing will not work well
for you in the long run.
I don't think you overreacted, you reacted appropriately. I also
don't think it's relevant which of the grandchildren's behavior
is best/worst because the problem is your father's reaction and
ways of dealing with misbehavior or any behavior that annoys
him, which all children will have at one time or another. There
is no way to force him to go to therapy or ''get it,but
No, you are not overreacting! While, yes it was wrong of your
son to climb on furniture it is typical behavior of a
six-year-old and you were aproching it just the right way. If
your children's grandfather can't control himself then you
shouldn't see him until he can!
There's one part of your weekend fiasco that I may be able to
shed some light on, since I have discovered th! is in myself.
When my mother is visiting at my house, or I have taken my kids
over to her house, I become ultra-sensitized to their behavior
and over react to little things they do. I've realized that this
is not about their behavior, but rather that she sees me, her
son as successful as a parent, and if they misbehave, that it's
a reflection on me. Your husband may be feeling the same
things, and doesn't realize it yet. Give him this insight...it
Tim in Berkeley
If I had to take a guess, your dad was probably less upset
with your son and more upset about the fight he was having
with his wife. He probably lashed out at you and your son
because of that. I don't say that to excuse his behavior, but if
you are taking the comments on your parenting personally,
I'd suggest that they were probably made in the heat of the
moment, and prob! ably did not reflect his real thoughts. It
sounds like you have alot of feelings about the whole
situation, that some of your own childhood experiences are
influencing your reactions now, and a counselor might be
able to help with that. You might decide that kind of
behavior isn't acceptable to you, or you might find a way to
respond that feels more comfortable to you. I doubt there is
a right answer to how we handle our parents and their
interactions with our children, but I have found it helpful to
work on my own issues with how I was parented in
mmaking decisions regarding how I deal with the present.
Phew! I just re-read your post and the archives, and having just
returned from Arizona visiting my in-laws, had to reply anyhow.
In our case, when invoking ''our doctor says...'', my MIL says ''I
would get ! another doctor in a heartbeat!'' And, my in-laws have
suggested we ''smack'' our kids because they don't pay attention
to our limit-setting. So, before this trip my husband and I
agreed if there was any physical ''limit setting'' on their part
that we would politely say ''we do not believe in that kind of
discipline'' and pack up and leave.
Married the Family Also
I think that parents make the rules whenever they are around.
Now that's not to say that if you allow jumping on the couch at
your house the children should be allowed to do it at the
grandparents house even if it is against their rules. But when
it comes to discpline, my rule of thumb for the last 7 years
has been, if I'm there, I'm in charge (or my husband). If I'm
not, then grandparents can alter the rules as long as SAFETY is
considered. I have very few rules when my kids sleep at either
of their grandparents. basically it comes down to don't go
near the pool without an adult, and listen to Grandma and
Grandpa. If my Dad wants to let my kids stay up late watching
a movie and eat candy all night, I don't really care. I think
the value of the Grandparent/grandchild relationship needs tobe
valued in that way.
To a ''Dear Abby'' out there:
I was just wondering how other parents handle ''toy fights'' at
a public space -- an example: your child has just become
fascinated by a toy or book at a park, library or other sort of
public space. Your child starts playing with it, and suddenly
another child comes to grab it as well -a pretty natural thing
to happen-. Your child looks at you with worry, and ends up
giving up the toy to the other child -- and the other parent
does nothing about it.
I always feel really reluctant to intervene, other than by
telling my child that it's ok to share. But I'd never tell the
other child to yield.
Is the other parent being rude by not intervening at all and
allowing his or her child take away the toy or book that my
child had chosen first? It even seems to me at times like the
parent is actually encouraging such behavior in the child,
sending him or her the message that it's ok to be ''the
I don't feel comfortable asking the other parent to talk to his
or her child, and I don't feel it's ok to correct anybody
else's children. But at the same time, it seems terribly wrong
that my child has to pay for other people's lack of courtesy
Thanks for any help or opinions on how to handle this,
A by-product of participating in a co-op preschool is that I now have no
reservations about intervening in such a situation. The trick is to
work the feelings of both children as best you can, but still protect
the child who is holding the toy first (it won't always be yours!). In
the best of all possible worlds, you intervene before the grabbing
happens - when you start to see the coveting looks from the other child,
you can say something like, ''Would you like a turn with the train next?
Jen's really good about sharing. If you tell her 'my turn next,
please', I bet she'd give it to you when she's done''. Then I'd make
sure my child's turn doesn't last indefinitely, which it generally won't
once they realize they're getting to choose the handoff point.
If the grabbing has already occurred, you can say ''Gosh, I don't think
Jen was finished yet. Let's work this out so you can both have turns''.
In most situations the parent/caregiver looks greatful, and most
preschoolers respond well to intervention from outside their own family
as long as it's done graciously.
As the parent of one fairly meek child (and one not) it was important
for my daughter to hear that she (and I) could stick up for her if need
be. Very quickly she learned to say ''I'm not finished yet''. She
sought adult assistance only until she was ready to handle it on her
a co-op fan
Alas, this is fairly common. Different parents have different ideas of
what's fair on the playground. And some parents keep a closer eye on
their kids. And some parents believe in less intervention with kids.
When my son was younger and another child came up to him and took a toy
or book that he was looking at, I would say hello to the child and ask
them if they liked that book too? Then I would say that my son was
looking at it first, and that it's not really okay with us to take
things out of his hand, but that we would pass it on to the other child
when my son was finished. If the other parent was watching, i'd explain
the same thing to the parent. As my son grew older, I did less of the
talking directly and encouraged my son to stand up for himself this way.
The need to do this goes on, and I hope that these early lessons set a
As a parent I have a responsibility to model the correct behavior for my
And, I think it is incorrect behavior to allow someone to snatch
something out of my hand. Defending and protecting your child from poor
behavior is perfectly fine. It is perfectly correct to help your
children to know what to say in difficult situations.
Responses I would recommend for preverbal (parent says it) or verbal
-- When Tom is finished playing with that toy, you may have a turn ///
When I am done, you are next
-- It is Tom's turn with that toy right now, when he is finished you may
have a turn /// It is my turn right now
-- For older children, you can also help them broker a sharing
arrangement. I will play with it for XX minutes and then it will be
BTW... In my experience judging other parents will probably come back to
bite you. It is rare to encounter a parent who is negligent, mean or
unfair. It is much more common to encounter parents who are distracted
(lack of sleep, a sibling who requires attention or perhaps an
engrossing conversation with another parent.) Think of what you would
like another parent to do and think when your back is turned and your
child grabs the car! Almost all children are capable of both sharing
Robin Good.... (There must be a joke here...)
Boy, without even thinking I usually say something like ''No, sweetie,
we don't grab, we are going to share the X.'' I'm not mean, just firm.
If the thing belongs to the other kid and my kid gets upset, I might
soften and ask the other kid to say please and tell my son to say thank
you. But I definitely speak up. Who cares if the other parent's there
and saying nothing. They might not have seen what happened, or maybe
they jsut don't care. But I don't want to model that sort of bad
behavior (the kid's and the parent's) for my son.
Same goes for hitting, by the way. Some 2ish kid poked my 18 mo in the
eye the other day and looked surprised when I told him ''No! We don't
poke people in the eye.'' I probably should have thrown in a ''It hurts
them,'' too, but there's also no way I'm going to let my already pretty
gentle son think it's okay to be pushed and poked around by other kids!
Happy to speak up
Alas, this is fairly common. Different parents have different ideas of
what's fair on the playground. And some parents keep a closer eye on
their kids. And some parents believe in less intervention with kids.
When my son was younger and another child came up to him and took a toy
or book that he was looking at, I would say hello to the child and ask
them if they liked that book too? I'd try not to make the other child
feel bad, but would try to model good behavior. Then I would say that
my son was looking at it first, and that it's not really okay with us to
take things out of his hand, but that we would pass it on to the other
child when my son was finished. If the other parent was watching, i'd
explain the same thing to the parent. As my son grew older, I did less
of the talking directly and encouraged my son to stand up for himself
this way. The need to do this goes on, and I hope that these early
lessons set a good foundation.
I am distressed by these same situations. When another child wants the
toy my daughter has (in a social, toy sharing
situation) I have always felt it is my responsibilty to teach my
daughter to share with the other child. Now that she is 3, I realize
how passive and timid she is of other children. Other children continue
to take toys out of her hands, or cut infront of her at the slide. Her
face goes sad when this happens and she shyly backs away, either
complaining to me or telling me she doesn't want to play. And I also
realize that while some parents think that taking toys from eachother is
typical behavior, not all children do it. It is a behavior that can be
expected of young toddlers, but I feel that they should be edcuated
about respect and sharing when it occurs. My new approach to help my
daughter be more assertive AND respectful of others is to teach her to
say something like, ''I am still playing with this, can you find another
toy please.'' And then I tell her that she can play with the object of
desire a while longer, but then should give someone else a turn.
Ideally, the other parent would engage in the situation at that point
and help their child find another toy. But, that does not often happen.
I only wish that I had taught my daughter from an earlier age to
advocate for herself. I think I was afraid she would become one of the
''bullies.'' I too, would feel uncomfortable correcting someone else's
chid. But I have to wonder, by letting children take toys from her when
she was younger, did I model social timidness? Maybe, maybe not. I will
say that I am very proud of my daughter because she is tolerant and
respectful of her peers. And I am sure her assertiveness will continue
When the children were really little, I would somewhat stick up for my
child by firmly telling the other child, ''Suzie isn't finished with it
yet. You can have the next turn.'' while putting my hand firmly on the
toy until they let go. Then tell my child, ''You can play with it for
two more minutes, then this little girl would like a turn. Remember,
this toy is for everyone to play with.'' I think it's important for my
child to know she didn't do anything wrong and I support her and at the
same time let the other child know that they will get a turn and when.
Of course, my child may not be done in two minutes, but I make sure that
the other child gets it. I ''help'' my child by counting down the time
which also helps the other one wait.
I've never had a problem with other parents. In fact, most other
parents appreciate it when another parent gently and kindly helps out in
a playground altercation. I know I do.
It's hard to be 100% aware of what your child is doing at all times
(especially when you have more than one.) I think it's also great when
another parent reinforces cooperative behavior.
As long as the other parent isn't yelling at my child or scaring them,
but being kind and firm.
I wanted to answer your post because I identified myself in what you
were saying when my first child was a toddler. I have always been
taught to have manners, extend courtesies, be polite, share, etc. When
my child was a toddler and we were out in public at the park or library
we found ourselves in the situation that you are experiencing. My child
would be enjoying something to have it taken away by another child..be
it a plastic shovel, book, etc. For more than a year I never said
anything to the other child or parent and mine would often be upset.
Many times we would have to leave and my line would be ''it's o.k.,
we're sharing.'' Well, grabbing something away from your child is not
sharing. It took me a second child and hundreds of outings before I
realized my mistake here. Do not think that other parents are going to
correct this behavior.
They may or may not see their child grabbing an item away. And it
doesn't matter if they do. It is your duty as a mother to stand up for
your toddler by saying firmly but very sweetly when another child starts
to grab,'Oh, no no my friend, my little boy/girl is looking at that
right now. You can look at it when we are done. See, here is another
for you right now). My child was so delighted when I learned to do this
with confidence and it really strengthened our bond and enjoyment of our
outings. I still think that manners count, but I made the mistake of
valuing being polite to strangers at the expense of my son's security.
a miss manners who cheerfully wards off grabbers
If other parents are not disciplining their own kids, you should not
hesitate to step in and say something yourself. Ask the child who is
misbehaving his/her name, and talk to the child. Introduce yourself and
the children to each other.
Explain what the problem is and suggest a solution or compromise. This
toy is your child's and he was playing nicely with it and it is not nice
to take it away. Suggest to the other child that he try asking for the
toy instead of taking.
Don't hesitate to gently take away your child's toy, talking through
what you are doing helps. Usually the other parent will begin to
participate once you start talking to their child.
If someone was grabbing from my child and the parent was for some reason
not intervening, I think I would say something to the child like, ''I
think (your child's name) was not quite done with that (toy name).
Would you like a turn when she's done?''
and hope that helps. I wouldn't grab it back or launch into a speech,
but wouldn't just watch either. If it became a real problem for your
kid, I think it would be appropriate to politely ask the other parent
for some support.
I also don't correct other people's children unless they are very close
friends/family or the kids are really out of hand.
I've been in the same situation you described with my son and I'm trying
to teach him not to grab, I know they take ques from other kids so I say
something like, ''it wasn't very nice of him to grab that toy'' (if he
seems upset). I also make sure to tell him how nice it is of him to take
turns and that he can have another turn when that child is done then I
try to distract him with another toy.
There are some important factors that you didn't mention that enter into
my thoughts. If the children that you are talking about are under three
then they are not being rude or being bullies. They are unaware that
there is any ownership. Also, if your child does not protest in any way
other than a look that you recognize the other parent probably is not
aware that your child was not done with the book/toy, etc.
My friend has a great way to deal with those situations. When a child
takes something away that her child is not done with she gently takes it
back and lets the other child know that her child was not done and in
five minutes (or whatever length of
time) your child will share. That conveys the message that you can
stick up for yourself and share.
As a parent of three I have to tell you that all children take toys away
from others. The way to tell that something is worth having is to see
it in someone else's hands. If one of my children took something from
your child I would not mind if you said something to my child. I am
trying to teach my children about sharing, but don't always catch them
when they are not sharing.
As a rule I try to give other parents the benefit of the doubt and treat
their children they way I want them to treat my children.
We don't have many rules and I generally stay out of the kids
interacting unless they're hurting each other, but we do have a no
grabbing rule. And if my son grabbed something from someone, I would
have no problems with someone else telling him not to, even if it wasn't
our rule. I feel our kids and ourselves need to learn to respect other
peoples ways and wishes even if we don't agree with them. If it bothers
you, it bothers you and I'd like to know it, even if I don't like it or
I don't believe the other parent is being rude at all if they don't
intervene under that particular circumstance. I would rather see the
kids work it out. If things do get out of hand, I would intervene and
talk to the children, but I wouldn't correct or expect the parent to
handle it if it didn't bother them.
About worrying your child is having to pay for other people's lack of
courtesy and manners. I look at it as the sooner and more they are
exposed to that, the more they will learn how to deal with it in their
own way. I don't feel sorry for my son, I look forward to him figuring
out how to deal with it and be ok with it, because it's going to happen.
my 2 cents
I don't think other toddlers are being a bully when they take a toy from
another child. They simply want the toy, so they take it. If a child
took a toy from my kid, and my kid was okay with it, I'd let it slide.
If not, might say to them, ''He's (my child) is still using that. Let's
take turns. When he's (my child) done, you'll get a turn, too.'' Then
they can practice taking turns with toys. It's possible that my child
will end his turn quickly and pass it on to the other kid to try out the
taking turns thing.
I think many adults get hung up on children's behavior because we see it
with all of our adult baggage. Very young children (even some adults!)
have a hard time understanding the concept of sharing. I try to give the
benefit of the doubt and offer to facilitate generosity and
graciousness, instead of getting all defensive and angry. Chances are
the instigator had no negative feelings towards anyone and was just
showing normal toddler interst in the toy.
i felt the same way when my dauhtgher started hanging out at
playgrounds. she is a pretty mellow kid and would always be the one
giving up the toy that she was playing with when a stronger kid would
grab it out of her hands. eventually, after a few months of this, i
decided that it wasn't fair and that i had to do something. i did not
talk to the mother, who obviously had a much different approach to
discipline than me -so why bother-, but i did explain to the other kid
about sharing and taking turn. i got down to the kid's eye level to talk
to him/her.that generally gets the other mom's attention and if she
overhears my comment, maybe -hopefully- she will learn from it and be
more 'on top' of her kid next time she takes him/her to the playgroung.
it has never caused a scene and the other kid has generally been
cooperative. also, i felt like my daughter could feel that i was
standing up for her and i felt real good about it. once you do it a
couple of times, it becomes really easy.
You might try telling your own child ''It's OK to keep the toy and say
you don't want to share right now.'' That MAY prompt the other mama to
point a different toy out to her child and say, ''it's not your turn,
that child is playing with that toy,
here have this one.'' Of course that mama might also think
you're now the rude one sticking up for your own child :) It's a
delicate balance, teaching our kids to stand up for themselves and to
learning to teach too
Initially I just used such incidents as an opportunity to encourage my
daughter (2 1/2 y/o) to share, but I soon realized that she was being a
doormat and needed to learn to stand up for herself a bit. Now I
sweetly tell the other child that it's my daughter's turn right now, and
that as soon as she's finished playing then other child can have a turn.
And I tell my daughter that it's OK to keep playing with the object
because it's her turn, but that when she's finished she should give it
to the other child. I figure any parent who has a problem with that is
kind of loopy -- it's never happened yet. When parents have multiple
kids with them they can't hover over every one of them. And if they're
just ignoring their child's misbehavior, well, it takes a village. If
without my knowledge my daughter were acting up, I would appreciate her
being gently reminded of good behavior from an adult who saw what
Three things that I think you need to mindful of when correcting your
child or other people's children are:
1) Your child and other children are not born with a set of ''manners.''
2) Your child is looking to you as to what to do in this situation.
3) What do want to teach your child?
What I have done in the past is to tell the other child that he or she
can have a turn after your child is done.
(Depending on the age) I have also invited the child to play together.
Or, I invited the child in my care to play with something different.
I have almost always intervened with some type of resolution that I felt
If the parent or caregiver came over I would explain what was going on.
We might end up in an interesting conversation, they might take the
child away or do whatever.
Nanny in the know
If my child had a toy first, really wanted to continue to play with it,
didn't have the language skills to speak up for him/herself and I felt
like getting involved, I'd tell the other child ''Right now it's (my
child's name)'s turn but your turn can be next.''
Then I'd make sure to get the toy to the other child when my kid lost
interest in it.
On the other hand when my daughter was a toddler, she used to give up
toys, turns, whatever to the point that I worried that she was a wimp
and would never stick up for herself. Then she grew up a bit and turned
into an assertive kid who only deferred to others if she felt like it.
I think that it is the other child's parent that should intervene in
these cases, but they don't always see or may be too occupied.
In which case, I do what the teachers at my childrens' preschool do and
say ''Joe, tell him that you had that book and you want it back.'' Their
teachers work on the kids that let their classmates take from them or
''bully'' them just as much as the taker/bully b/c it's important that
your child learns to standup for herself.
Maybe if you approach it this way, the other parent will hear you and
help out, and not be offended since it is more like you're teaching your
kid how to act in this situation instead of theirs.
By the way, my kids' teachers would say to the taker/bully ''Lisa, ask
Joe if you can have it when he's done.'' A few times I have said to
another child ''Joe is still looking at that, but he would be glad to
tell you when he's done with it'' but I think this isn't always the best
thing to do for my kid.
mom of 2
I always correct other people's children if the parent (or
nanny) doesn't intervene first. If a child tries to grab or take away a
toy from my child, I approach the other child and tell him/her something
like ''my son was playing with this toy.
You may have it when he is done with it. Please give the toy back to my
son.'' I say it with a pleasant but firm tone of voice and I may repeat
this several times and if the child doesn't give the toy back, I try to
gently take it saying ''my son was playing with that and it's not nice
to take toys away from others without asking for it first.'' If the
child won't reliquish the toy, I won't force it from him as I don't want
to teach him (or my child) that you can take things from people by
force. I then tell the child that that wasn't nice and he should give
the toy back, and then I let it go. I tell my child that I'm sorry the
other kid took his toy (within ear shot of the other kid) and I help my
child find something else to play with. Never feel bad about
intervening with other kids. How else will they learn? And your child
too? By intervening, you teach your child to be assertive and to not
let people walk all over him, without being aggressive or being a bully.
You can show your child that it is fair to ask the other kid for his toy
back, but not to be too forceful about it and to drop a situation if it
becomes too difficult or physical. The parent or nanny of the other kid
should intervene and give back a toy that was taken from your kid, but
sometimes they are tired, are unaware of what happened, or are rude and
don't care, so you must intervene.
When I run into situations like these, I try to help both kids take
turns. I think it is just fine to help other people's kids whose
parents/caregivers are not right there maneuver through these types of
encounters. If my son had something & another child came over &
it from him, I would tell the other child that my son was playing with
that & that when he is finished he (other kid) can have a turn. If the
kid put up a big stink & the caregiver still neglected to come over to
help, I guess I would probably tell the kid that the toy/book is for
everyone to look at/play with & maybe we could all do it together. If
that still didn't work, I would probably just remove my child & myself
from the area & leave it to the caregiver to deal with. It rarely, if
ever, gets to that point. Most times, the kid either loses interest or
my son will.
I don't really think there is anything wrong with helping another kid
through these things. Sometimes the caregiver didn't see the encounter
& doesn't realize the issue is as big as you see it. Either way, it
really does take a village & as long as we are respectful of each kid
the situation, there shouldn't be a problem. Also, your child needs to
learn how to deal with those situations too. As s/he gets older, you
won't always be around to protect him, so by modeling behavior as to
to handle these types of encounters you are showing him how to try to
work through it. One more thing, I don't really think it's fair to
label a kid a bully for wanting the same toy as your kid. I don't know
the details, but please try to remember that that behavior is, as you
stated, pretty normal for small children.
Working for a better community for all of our children
if my child was playing with a toy first and another grabs it, i
generally (but not always) use my ''words'' and say, ''my little one
playing with that first, please give it back.'' with time the grabbers
usually do hand the toy over. i wouldn't ask for the toy back if it
belonged to the child who took it. but i might add, ''please don't
toys, please ask for them first'', then give the toy back to the child.
such verbalizations help my child understand how things should be done
in a perfect world, although they may not be happening as i would like
them to happen. and be nice. we just all need to try to get along!
asking a parent to intervene shouldn't be necessary, you can handle the
children around your children, i'd think. just be nice and help them
understand how to be good friends to one another in the park.
Best to you!
I've had the same issues with my 16.5 month old, though he is often the
one doing the taking. I always try to intervene with him, sometimes
even picking him up and moving him to a different, but similar toy.
I've also experienced another mom ''discipling'' my child when he was
trying to take their child's toy (I was distracted talking to another
mom). And while at first I felt offended, in the end I was ok that she
stepped in (the child was older and bigger and could have hurt my son
had a major conflict occurred). When I noticed what was happening I
came over, and the mom was saying to my son that it was her daughter's
turn, and after he was finished he could have his turn. He looked at
me, and tried to take the toy again, so I re-directed him both
physically and verbally ''let's go play with this truck over here, when
she's finished with that truck we can have our turn'' etc. In the end,
the girl brought the toy over to him when she was finished, and he
played with it a bit, then took it back to her (very cute). I have
intervened when a child was trying to take a toy my son was using, with
no negative responses from the parent, by offering another toy that was
similar. I think most parents are understanding, I know at the park i
try to give my son space to play and interact with the other children
without being overbearing and sometimes I miss the interaction. I
have any sage words of wisdom, I play it by ear, and sometimes I let
other kids win. My son just moves on to something else with relative
ease, and a little re-direction.
trying to navigate parental manners in public spaces too
I feel strongly that it's wrong to let a kid treat another badly. Not
everyone sees it my way. My job is to guide my kid through the world
with self-respect & a sense of fairness. If a kid grabs something mine
is playing with, I want mine to know it's ok to object. If my kid grabs
something from another, I tell her it's not okay, & I may remove her,
tantrum or not. I expect other parents to do the same, but they may
If the other parent doesn't pay attention or doesn't care & my kid
doesn't know how to respond, I help her. I tell the kid, I'm sorry, she
was playing with it, you can have it when she's done.
Then I ask mine to give it to the other kid when she's done. My child
needs to know that I value her enough to help her negotiate w/ people
who may not have the social skills we'd prefer, & she knows I'll
her if needed. If a kid whacks my kid, I have NO problem telling the
it's not okay. If the other parent isn't there or won't correct the
I will. No guilt. I try to do what seems best, but I'm not perfect. We
were playing in a pool, &I nicely asked a bigger kid several times not
to jump on top of us. I didn't see a parent. He got out of the pool,
a hacking cough & runny nose, & wiped his mouth & nose along 4ft of
railing (really). So gross I almost threw up. I asked him nicely if he
could use a tissue instead. I got out of the pool to clean it. Suddenly
Mom appears & yells at me, tells me to come to her first. Maybe I
have, but I was so appalled & didn't even know who she was. Am I
obligated to track down an uninvolved parent? I spoke to a parent
when her teenager splattered paint all over me and my kid, & was
for that too! I can't count on other people's behavior, so I take care
of myself &establish firm boundaries. I want my kid to do this too. We
teach our kids what we feel is important, & take the consequences. You
can't avoid all confrontations. You may offend or be offended. So what
if someone thinks I'm ridiculous?
Is is ever appropriate to teach some discipline to a neighbor's
child? Our neighbor's child sits on our fence and blows her
whistle to gain our son's attention. He then runs into the
backyard to talk to her. She is 6 and he is 4. This is noisy
and annoying. What should I do? Her parents have said
nothing. I make gentle remarks like, ''Please be careful...Don't
fall from the fence...Wow what a loud toy..'' Should I be more
firm and say we need privacy and quiet? Or should I let kids be
kids?? What do I teach my own son about our rules versus their
rules? We have told him that is is not good manners to shout
over the fence...
I think kids shouting to each other over the fence is one of the most
practiced communication methods that exists. I would honestly be happy
to hear such an exchange, or rather, a beckoning from the neighbor child
to mine. I think the focus would be on explaining to your child and the
other child that while the invitations are appreciated, it is not always
the right time to play, and momma has to be asked first, etc. The
whistle will probably get outgrown. In the meantime, relish in the fact
your child has a friend who wants to play with him all the time.
Are your kids good friends? If they are, and you're ok with them
playing together then maybe you can foster their relationship. How
great would be it be to have a good friend living right next door! Try
this out - a version of the ''telephones'' we had growing up - give them
Explain the rules: use during play time, not meal times, homework time,
and they are turned off at bed time. this way you have a little more
control too, i.e. you can tell your son that he can't go out to play
just yet because he has X, Y, or Z to do, you can talk to your
neighbor's kid and tell her that right now is not a good time, etc., and
you won't have a little kid sitting on top of your fence whistling (that
could also be a liability issue since you are aware of the problem).
Anyway, good luck with dealing with the problem without totally
alienating your neighbors.
If you know what you consider to be appropriate behavior for your child,
in your yard (or on your fence) I would urge you to be ''old fashioned''
and extend your expectations to the visiting child. Dropping hints and
wishing for better behavior is a disservice to everyone involved. When
we were kids it was easier, because there was a more uniform concept of
what acceptable behavior was. Where I grew up any good parent could
reinforce reasonable behavior for any good kid.
If you're worried about offending the neighbors by expecting reasonable
behavior from their child.... initiate a discussion with the parents in
which you agree to rules for each house that will be respected by both
kids (noise, food, supervision, etc). If you're lucky you'll have the
same family next door ten years from now, and have developed a positive
If you're not willing to have the discussion, or you think the
neighbor's rules would be out of line, or hazardous to your child...
well, that's a different, more serious problem.
Yes, you should of course discipline your neighbors child when he is on
your property and/or interacting with you or your child. I have always
counted on friends and neighbors to help me teach my children how to
respect others. And I respect their right to have rules that are
different than ours.
When I first moved to Berkeley, the girl next door struck up a
friendship with my daughter. The girl was a few years older, but had
very poor behavior. After letting it drive me nuts for awhile, I decided
that she wasn't going away and that I would have to discipline her in
some basics. I explained the rules that we had ''at our house,'' and
that she would have to abide by when she was with us. I kept a close eye
on her (I had to anyway, since she could come up with the most amazing
mischeif that my kids would never think of..) When she broke a rule, I
walked her home immediately. This happend quite often at first, but I
put a lot of energy into it and soon my daughter had a normally-behaved
playmate. It was work, but worth it in that it brought a sense of normal
control back to our environment when she was over. And I'm sure it did
One time her oblivious parents commented to me, ''She is so well behaved
at your house!''
It sounds like you're really sensitive to what the neighbors might think
about the whistling, but barring early morning or late night, I wouldn't
think anyone would mind.
My son recently found out that our katty corner neighbor has a son of
the same age and they went through a period when neighbor would whistle
for our son. My son would yell or blow a whistle (he can't whistle) and
it went on that way for about a week. Then they both moved on to other
As someone who always dreamt of having a friend in the neighborhood, I
thought it was great, but just so you know, no one complained or seemed
to care. Don't forget, during the day, many of the neighbors are at
Now if it were honking, that would be another matter....
I would speak with the child's parents. Tell them that you are concerned
for the safety of both kids and that you find the whistle blowing very
loud. Once you get the girl's parents to agree that her behavior is not
ok, and they let her know this, then I think it's appropriate to
reinforce the agreed upon rule by telling her to get off the fence. You
also might suggest that the kids be given opportunities from time to
time to get together on one side of the fence or the other.
A nice rule of thumb is by examining who the behavior impacts and whose
space is it in?
You have every right to erect boundaries for your space. A shared fence
is partially yours, and if she is calling into YOUR backyard, you ahve
every right to tell her to stop. Also address it with her parents, outta
respect for them. Just let them know it's not okay with you that she
yells into your yard and sits at the top, with the potential to fall
onto your property. It's pretty cut and dry in this case. You don't have
to put up with it.
If you were having lunch at their house, however, and she was yelling in
the backyard, or climbing too high on things they own (but not climbing
on YOU), it really is their choice what she's allowed to do.
Best of luck!
Since the girl is only 6 years old, you should speak with the parents.
Her parents might think you are okay with it because your son responds
to the whistle.
I have a friend who has a child the same age as mine, and our
kids play together alot. It's come to my attention that this
other parent feels free to discipline my child while I'm
standing right there, and NOT in a way I'm confortable with (a
3rd party asked if I was bothered by this). For example, my
child ate some fruit and hasn't had his face washed, so this
parent told my child in an abrupt way he couldn't play until his
face was wiped clean. I dont' think it's place to make that call
when I'm right there. Besides, I was getting a wipe out at the
time to wipe his face... Or, my child might try to take a toy
away from her child (I'm of the mindset that the kids can figure
it out for themselves, as long as they seem like they want to--
especially since they're only 2 yrs old), so she'll jump in,
grab it from my kid, and them reprimand him rather harshly. Her
child does the same thing 50% of the time, and my approach in
the past has been to point out that the other kid was using it
first, they can take turns, and ''oh-- isn't that a nice toy over
there that you can play with...''
What can I do about this? It's getting to be more and more
frequent, and I don't want to end this friendship. I just don't
want her disciplining my son while I'm right there.
easy-going mama (trying to be!)
Your friend sounds like an insecure parent and it's causing her
to compete with every other parent in the room. She also sounds
like a bit of a bully.
Sadly, I don't think there's much you can do about this unless
some of the other moms have noticed and would be willing to say
something to her as well. I think most people who exhibit this
kind of behavior are usually convinced that it's everyone else's
kid whose the problem--not theirs.
I would think she'll react defensively if you speak with her
directly about it but you could try. She'll probably tell you
she's just trying to help, the implication being that you really
need help because you aren't as competent as she is.
You could also try waiting until it comes up again and say
something like, ''Don't worry, I've got this one'' but it might be
hard find an opportunity for this. If it really drives you crazy,
you may have to limit your interactions with her. Just be
thankful she isn't a family member so you aren't stuck with forever.
Best of luck!
It sounds as if you and your friend have some fundamental
differences in child rearing. Your friend probably doesn't think
you jump in/guide enough and as it is most likely her philosophy
she will do so not only to guide but also to protect her child.
I was in the same position with a friend and we just ended up
seeing each other without our children - dinner, movies, walks.
This has preserved our friendship which we both value.
Incidently, on the note of guiding vs letting them sort it out,
I think it is important to show children guidance in the social
graces. If you let them ''sort it out'' typically the more
assertive/aggressive child will always win and both children
learn less than positive messsages from that scenario. Think of
going to another country - you have to be told the social
customs/ policies, this not something you can just sort out for
yourself without guidance. Left to yourself you make all sorts
of faux pas unknowingly. My friends son was left to sort it out
himself and now at 6 yrs old is aggressive, bossy, pocessive and
generally anti social. This child boy is never asked for play
dates and is shunned in the play ground because he just doesn't
know how to act in a socially acceptable manner. He is confused,
angry and sad. He is also now in a (expensive) social group
learning how to act in the defined social code of this culture!
Speaking to the toy-grabbing issue only, here's the perspective
of a mom who has recently decided to cross-discipline in this
area. You wrote that kids can ''figure it out for themselves^
especially since they're only 2.'' I believe that we can model
good behavior for our toddlers, and that they are too young
to ''figure it out for themselves.''
Occasionally, another child will grab a toy from my almost-2
year old. And she too, will occasionally calmly remove a toy
from another child's hands. I have decided that when I see my
daughter get that toy envy glint in her eye, I say ''No
grabbing'', talk about turns, and try to distract her. This
works really well with my little girl. Until recently, I was
silent when another kid grabbed from my daughter, b/c I'd hope
that the other mom would be vigilant like you are.
Unfortunately, I was disappointed repeatedly. The other mom
was either not there, not paying attention, or said nothing.
I also noticed that after another child grabbed from my child,
later in the day, my daughter would grab from someone else. So
now, when someone grabs from my girl, I say the same thing to
the other child that I say to my daughter- ''no grabbing.'' Does
it stop the other kid? No. But more importantly, my daughter
is getting consistent messages from me.
If my friends didn't like my approach, I'd want to know. One
would hope we could come up with some kind of compromise.
I'm not sure if my situation is the same as yours but here
goes: There are about a dozen kids in our complex and we share
a common play area. One of the kids does not play well with
others. She crashes, snatches, and throws toys; hits, pushes
and yells at the other kids. Eventually another kid will
retaliate or will be reduced to tears. The girl's mother, other
mothers, and teenage siblings are either right there with the
little ones or are within earshot. I have tried to, not
discipline, but redirect the girl's behavior many times. For
example, after asking her nicely five times to return another
kid's toy when the kid is having no luck getting it back
himself, she'll slam the toy to the ground. And my shock at
this response has caused me to be abrupt, not to ''discipline''
her but to protect the dynamics of the other kids' play and well
as protect their property. The mother gets very upset if
anyone, child or parent, says anything to or about the
daughter. She seems to be convinced that everyone is ''out to
get'' her daughter and explains her behavior by saying ''she is
only 4.'' Well, the other kids (ages 2-8) play well together and
do not purposely damage property on a regular basis. Sorry for
being long-winded, and not really giving advice, but sometimes
parents do get abrupt with other people's kids when the other
parent is right there.
You signed your question with ''easy going mama (or trying
to be)'', but I hope you don't confuse being easy going with
avoiding conflict! I would encourage you to talk to your friend
directly about this so you can find a way to work it out. You're
unhappy with this situation, and from what you describe of
her tone, I would guess that she is unhappy, too. Instead of
waiting for the next time this happens, talk about it BEFORE
it happens. Share with her you feelings (I'm guessing you
might be feeling annoyed and confused, and perhaps
protective?), and share with her what you need (I'm
guessing respect and consideration for both children,
gentleness and kindness toward both, and some
understaning of what's going on for your friend?). Then ask
her if she'd be willing to tell you what's going on for her. Now
you might want to be ready to hear stuff that might be hard to
hear.... Your friend MIGHT have some judgments - of you or
your child. She might not, but when you open a conversation
about parenting, there's always that possibility. If you can try
to hear your friend's feelings and needs underneath
whatever she tells you, it's more likely that you'll be able to
connect with her. I would guess that she might feel
concerned and want to protect her child? Perhaps she feels
irritated because she wants more confidence that each
parent is paying attention to and taking care of their
children's needs? (You might be doing just that, but it might
not be in the timeframe or in the way that are comfortable for
your friend.) Getting clear on this can be an opportunity to
deepen your friendship and trust, by looking at both your
needs and trying to find ways to support one another without
trying to change each other (not a likely proposition anyway).
On the grabbing issue specifically, you might want to check
out the article I wrote about this subject for Neighborhood
Parents Network. It's posted on the website of the Center for
Nonviolent Communication, at www.cnvc.org, in the
parenting resources page. I'm not sure it will fit your
parenting style, but it just might help :-).
this page was last updated: Sep 22, 2012
BPN is now a 501(c)(3) non-profit and we are building a new website!
Read more, and see how you can help:
The opinions and statements expressed on this website
are those of parents who subscribe to the
Berkeley Parents Network.
Disclaimer & Usage for
information about using content on this website.
Copyright © 1996-2015 Berkeley Parents Network