Berkeley Parents Network
Google Custom Search
Home Members Post a Msg Reviews Advice Subscribe Help/FAQ What's New

BPN Rules & Policies

Berkeley Parents Network > Help & Frequently Asked Questions > BPN Rules & Policies


Policies for All the Newsletters Policies for Specific Newsletters UC Berkeley Policies

Questions


The Rules

The goal of the Parents Network lists is to be useful to parents and to provide a sympathetic discussion forum for the community of parents. To keep the list as friendly as possible, there are a few rules:

The newsletter moderators are responsible for deciding whether members meet the above guidelines. We may return or edit messages that we decide are not in keeping with the policies, or that we feel are otherwise inappropriate for the list. Members who do not abide by the rules will be unsubscribed from the list at the moderators' discretion.

Do you ever reject messages?

Yes. We return messages to the sender to edit if they do not meet our policies. Sometimes this happens because we think the message may sound critical of other parents, or it doesn't conform to the "negative review" policy. Occasionally people send in advertising or chain letters that we reject. Although we prefer to return letters to the sender for editing, we do sometimes edit messages for length or content ouselves in order to get the newsletter out on time with your posting.

The moderators must judge for themselves whether messages meet the policies, which have been developed over 10 years and are still evolving. We can't guarantee 100% that we always apply all the policies equally and fairly, but that is what we try very hard to do.


Do you ever unsubscribe people for breaking the rules?

Yes, but not often. In 10 years of running the list for thousands of subscribers, we have unsubscribed fewer than 10 people who didn't want to be unsubscribed. They have all been extreme cases of the policies being violated even after warnings. For example, one person was phoning subscribers who had posted messages in a discussion about safety at a local school. If she disagreed with someone's comment in the newsletter, she would look them up in the phone book and call them at home. We asked her to stop and she didn't stop, so we had to unsubscribe her in order to protect other subscribers' privacy. Twice we have had to unsubscribe people for repeatedly sending hostile emails to the moderators about editorial decisions they disagreed with. We have also unsubscribed a few people for misusing the Marketplace newsletter. In one case, a mail order violin company was posing as a parent with an instrument for sale. In another case, a member was collecting free items from Craigslist and then re-selling them on the Marketplace.


Disparaging others' parenting decisions

We do not accept postings that criticize other parents' decisions about how to raise their children. You may describe your own parenting techniques and say why you think they have worked well, but you may not cast aspersions on others' techniques and parenting decisions that differ from yours. See also the sections about Preaching and Politeness.


Getting personal

We do not accept postings that criticize other people, unless the post is a negative review of a person that BPN considers to be a business. See Negative reviews for information about this. All other posts must refrain from making critical comments about other people. This includes mentioning a person by name as well as providing enough detail about a person that he or she is recognizable. The friend, neighbor, or ex-husband that you are criticising is likely to be a fellow BPN subscriber. We don't want anyone's feelings to be hurt, so that we can meet our goal of being a helpful and supportive resource for parents.


What is the geographic area for BPN postings?

We are not able to accept requests for pediatricians, schools, childcare centers, real estate agents, and other services in areas outside of the San Francisco Bay Area. We consider the SF Bay Area to go about as far north as Richmond/Pinole, as far south as Hayward, as far east as Lamorinda & Walnut Creek, and as far west as San Francisco.

We ask this because not many of our subscribers live outside of this area. In fact, most of our subscribers live in the Easy Bay cities of Berkeley, Oakland, Albany and surrounding areas. Therefore, out-of-area requests are not likely to get responses. They place a disproportionate burden on the volunteer moderators and are not likely to be of general interest to our subscriber pool.

We are happy to take more general requests such as "Moving to...." or "Vacationing In...", as long as they are parenting/family related. These frequently get excellent and useful responses for popular destinations (Boston, DC or Hawaii) and fewer or no responses for less popular destinations (Boise, Glendale). We don't accept travel questions that are more fully answered elsewhere, such as "need a hotel near the Rome airport". See Travel Questions for details.


Gossip

We do not accept postings that have the appearance of gossip. Usually we would consider a post to be gossip if it had a phrase like "I heard that ..." followed by some criticism of a person, place, service, or product. For example, we can't accept a posting about a specific school that mentions criticisms that have been heard from friends and neighbors. On the other hand, we do accept criticisms that are based on first-hand experience as long as they follow our Negative Review Policy.


Political Announcements

We do post political announcements in two cases:

1) At election time we usually send out a one-time "Special Election Edition" which allows subscribers to express their thoughts about candidates and propositions that have some bearing on the family and parenting. Rules for these special issues are online at parents.berkeley.edu/election_rules.html. When we are not able to put together a special issue, members may post a message to the Announcements newsletter at election time as long as it follows the rules for the special election issues.

2) Between elections, we post newsworthy events that we think subscribers would be interested in. They need to be related to parenting or children. The right place to post these is in the Announcements newsletter, in the "Other Announcements" section. The announcement must be a personal note from a subscriber who includes his/her name and email address in case there are questions. We can't accept mass-mailings that have been forwarded to many people. Any names, addresses, emails, dates, phone numbers, or web sites that are contained in the message must be verified by the subscriber. The best method is to write a short personal note and include a website that people can go to for additional information.

We do not accept messages about political fundraisers.


Privacy Policy

The Berkeley Parents Network is meant to be a supportive, helpful forum for parents. We do everything we can to protect the privacy of subscribers so that we will all feel comfortable discussing sensitive topics about ourselves and our families.
  1. We do not use any of the information you give us when you subscribe for anything except the "Welcome New Members" section of the newsletter, which goes only to other subscribing parents. If you do not want your name to appear in the Welcome section, you have the option to request that on the subscription form.

  2. We save only your email address in order to mail newsletters to you. We do not store your name or your neighborhood or the ages of your children, or any other information you give us other than your email address.

  3. We do not give away or sell or reveal names or email addresses for any other reason, ever.

  4. Most of the newsletters allow you to specify how you want your posting to be signed. You can sign with just your first name, or your full name and email address, or any other moniker including "Anonymous". Exceptions to this are the postings where a contact email/phone is needed, such as the Marketplace and Childcare newsletters. See Can I post anonymously? for more information about this.

  5. When we archive advice and reviews to the website, we remove all identifying information first unless you have given us permission to post it (such as tutor announcements.) Full names, email addresses, phone numbers, etc., are never included, even if you included it in your original post to the newsletter. Please let us know immediately if you find that your name was accidentally included on a web page, and we'll remove it at once.

  6. Be aware that when you post a message to one of the newsletters, it will be seen by thousands of people. There are 21,714 subscribers receiving the BPN newsletters, so it's very possible that your neighbor, your co-worker, your boss, or your child's teacher is on the list. Please keep this in mind. And, as always with any kind of written correspondence, please be prudent about what you put into your email if you are signing your name to it.

  7. Subscribers may not forward newsletters to non-subscribers without permission. The newsletters often contain personal information about subscribers such as their full names, childrens' names, phone numbers, home addresses, and email addresses. As with any other email you receive, you should never forward the words of, or personal information about, another person without their permission. We think it is OK to forward some good advice to a friend in another state but please remove all the personal information first, or ask the permission of the people who posted.

  8. It is not allowed for anyone to contact any poster for ANY reason other than responding directly to the question they asked in their post. You may NOT offer any other service, advice, or recommendation that they did not ask for specifically. We want subscribers to feel that they can include their email address in their post without being bombarded with unwanted email from other subscribers. It is OK to send somebody an email that answers the question they asked, or to say thanks, or to say hello to a friend. Most people are happy to receive email like this. But it is not OK to send another subscriber any email that would be considered unwelcome by most people. This includes criticism about a posting of theirs you saw in the newsletter, and anything that could be interpreted as advertising. Example 1: if you see a posting in the newsletter that you disagree with or disapprove of, you may not phone or send email to the person who posted to comment or complain to them about the posting unless they specifically invited people to write them with comments. See Can't I express my opinion when I think a letter is offensive or another parent is wrong?. Example 2: a subscriber who runs a nanny agency may not take email addresses from the newsletter in order to send people information about their business. In both of these cases, the email is assumed to be unwanted and the privacy of a subscriber is being violated.
The moderators will do their best to make sure that the privacy of subscribers is protected. Subscribers who are unable to follow the newsletter policies on privacy will be unsubscribed.

Chain Letters

Chain letters are not allowed, per The Rules above. Here's how we decide if it's a chain letter: If it has lots of forwards >>>> , or there are a bunch of email addresses at the end, or BPN was only one of many addresses it was sent to, or it says "Send this to everyone you know!", then we consider it a chain letter.

The main reason is that if we use the newsletter to "get the word out" to as many people as possible about a favorite cause, the newsletter will quickly become too large to be useful, and too onerous to plow through.

The second reason is that many chain letters are hoaxes. A good website to check for hoaxes is http://www.snopes.com/.


Donation Requests

Members can post to the Marketplace newsletter asking for non-cash donations for their child's school, their church, or any other non-profit organization. Examples: donations for a school rummage sale or non-profit parenting organization, baby clothes for low-income parents at the county hospital, office supplies for a public school, and the like. However, we cannot accept requests for money, such as marathon pledges or cash donations to non-profit organizations. Announcements about many fundraising events are allowed - see the next section.


Fundraising Events & Sales

If your church, public school, non-profit private school, or community organization is holding a fundraiser that is open to the public, you can send an announcement to the appropriate newsletter ... Marketplace for garage sales & rummage sales, Parents of Teens for high school events, and/or Announcements for walkathons, car washes, auctions, and similar events.

Many parents are interested in attending these as a way of learning more about a school or other organization in the community.

Fundraising events for other non-profit organizations can also be posted to the Announcements newsletter as long as the organizations are related to parenting and families, such as Twins by the Bay, Bananas, YMCA, etc.

We cannot accept announcements about fundraising events for organizations that are not somehow parenting- or family-related, or are not typically events that children would attend. For example, fundraisers for politicians, medical conditions, and adult-centered organizations are not accepted.

It is OK to post items to the Marketplace that are being sold to raise money for your child's non-profit school, sports team, chorus, and similar groups, or for other non-profit family-related community organizations such as city parks, parenting groups, and the like. Many parents are interested in purchasing these items if they support local schools, parks, etc. However, to avoid having a Marketplace newsletter full of ongoing ads for non-profits, please stick to the items sold during fundraising drives as opposed to merchandise that is always available for sale. Also be aware that most everyone with a child in school will be selling something at one time or another, so please don't rely on the Marketplace to get rid of all those boxes of gift wrap and candy!


Rules for UCB Mailing lists

We follow the UC Berkeley policies for mailing lists. For example, the list may not be used for commercial purposes, and the list owner must advise members of rules that apply to the list, and may remove members who don't follow the rules. For details on the policy, see UC Berkeley's Mailing List Policy at http://itpolicy.berkeley.edu:7015/e-Berkeley.policy.html#mass


Is it OK to use University resources to read and reply to the newsletter?

In general, it is OK for University staff & students to use University resources to send, receive and read personal email, as long as it does not interfere with their work and it abides by existing policies such as not using it for personal gain or for criminal use. (Note: your UCB email account is NOT considered private, however.) If you're interested in all the details, you can read the University's email policy here: http://www.ucop.edu/ucophome/policies/ec/


Q&A vs. Open-Ended Discussion

Some of the BPN newsletters are Question-and-Answer format, including Advice, Recommendations, and Schools. These newsletters are not meant for open-ended discussion. All postings should either ask a new question, or respond to a previous question. Comments about others' postings aren't accepted. General observations and comments that are neither questions nor answers are not accepted. Here's why: 1) open-ended discussions can generate a lot of long emails; it's too much overhead for the moderators, and it makes the newsletters too long. 2) open-ended discussions often elicit highly opinionated and impassioned postings that involve criticism of other parents, which isn't allowed, and whining, venting, and preaching, which isn't allowed.

There are two newsletters that do have a section for some kinds of discussion: the "Letters" section of Announcements and Teens. Postings for these sections must follow other newsletter policies though, including the policies about Negative reviews and Commenting on others' opinions.

You may also contact the moderator if you have a comment or a question about any postings that have appeared. The moderator's email address is shown at the top of the newsletter.


Unsolicited Reviews

BPN does not accept unsolicted reviews. An unsolicited review is a review for something that was not specifically requested in a recent newsletter. All reviews must be posted in response to a request in a recent newsletter.


Whining, Venting, and Preaching

Whining, Venting, and Preaching (WVP) aren't allowed in the BPN newsletters because they are not helpful to other parents, and being helpful is our main goal. A small amount of WVP in a posting that is mostly useful is OK. However, a posting that is mostly WVP will have to be returned to the sender.


Home   |   Reviews   |   Advice   |   Members   |   Post a Message
Join BPN   |   Help   |   What's New   |   Search   |   Contact Us

Last updated: Apr 19, 2008
Copyright © 1996-2008 Berkeley Parents Network


The opinions and statements expressed on this website are those of parents who subscribe to the Berkeley Parents Network. Please see Disclaimer & Usage for information about using content on this website.